|
|
Cryptosporidium: the public concern
Following is a brief description of the volatile organic contaminates regulated in Florida.
These organic chemicals are used in the manufacture of gasoline for airplanes and as solvents for pesticides, and as cleaners and degreasers of metals. They usually get into water by improper waste disposal. These chemicals have been shown to damage the liver, kidneys and nervous system of laboratory animals such as rats and dogs exposed to high levels during their lifetimes. Some humans who were exposed to relatively large amounts of these chemicals also suffered damage to the nervous system. EPA has set the drinking water standard for xylenes at 10 parts per million (ppm) to protect against the risk of these adverse health effects. Drinking water that meets the EPA standard is associated with little to none of this risk and is considered safe with respect to xylenes. Drinking Water Contamination by Dumps and LandfillsThursday, May 10, 2001
The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) estimates that between 0.1%
and 0.4% of usable surface aquifers are contaminated by industrial impoundments
and landfills (1). Dumps and landfills are a threat to water supplies when
water percolates through waste, picking up a variety of substances such
as metals, minerals, organic chemicals, bacteria, viruses, explosives,
flammables, and other toxic materials. This contaminated water is called
leachate and is produced when the waste becomes saturated with water (2).
Wastes with high moisture content or which receive artificial irrigation,
rainwater, surface or groundwater infiltration produce leachate and methane
gas. It has been shown that once a dump is saturated, annual precipitation
of 36 inches per year can percolate 1 million gallons of contaminated water
per acre (3). If the leachate is not contained and migrates from a site
the chemical and physical properties of the substances and the soil, as
well as the hydrogeological conditions around the site, will determine
the extent of contamination. If a leachate reaches ground or surface water
it could contaminate water supply wells.
Dumps and landfills are not entirely synonymous and a distinction should be made. A dump is defined as, " a site used to dispose of solid wastes without environmental controls." (4). The term 'landfill' is replacing 'dump' due to the modernization of our solid waste facilities. Landfill is defined as a "facility in which solid waste from municipal and/or industrial sources is disposed; sanitary landfills are those that are operated in accordance with environmental protection standards." (2) This distinction is very important because it allows us to distinguish between two different eras and practices. Even so, some modernized landfills are poorly engineered or located in an environmentally unsound areas. The upgrade of waste disposal sites from dumps to environmentally sound solid waste disposal systems was mandated by a set of hazardous waste amendments passed in 1986. Landfills are now regulated at one of three class levels depending on the nature of solid or hazardous waste accepted. Well designed landfills should not cause water quality problems because
leachate problems are anticipated and controlled. Return
to the top
Q What is Cryptosporidium and how is it transmitted?
Q What are the symptoms?
Q Who is at risk for severe Cryptosporidiosis?
Q Why is Cryptosporidium a problem in drinking water?
Q How can I tell if there is Cryptosporidium in my drinking water?
Q Is there a cure for Cryptosporidium infection?
Q Should I take extra protective measures?
A No. Boiled tap water is safe. Bottled water is safe provided it is treated by reverse osmosis, distilled or filtered through an absolute 1 micron or smaller filter. Q Can I take a shower or bath?
Q Can I use ice cubes already frozen?
Q Can I brush my teeth with tap water?
Q Is drinking water the only source of the parasite that causes
Cryptosporidiosis?
A See chart below
Return to the top
First detected in Europe only as recently as the 1980s, Cryptosporidium has often struck communities, which had until then enjoyed safe water with apparently high standards of filtration. In 1987, Cryptosporidium hit Carrollton, a university town in rural Georgia, USA. Thirteen thousand people out of a total population of 65,000, many of them students, fell ill with diarrhoea, stomach cramps and vomiting. The authorities discovered that every household on the water supply system received contaminated water, yet the town's filtration system complied fully with national filtration standards. In 1993 the City of Milwaukee, Wisconsin, suffered on an even bigger scale. 400,000 residents fell ill through contamination of the water system with four thousand residents hospitalised at an estimated cost of $54 million. There have also been over a dozen outbreaks reported in the United Kingdom. What worries health authorities is Cryptosporidium's resistance to many traditional treatments including chlorination, rendering much of the treatment process irrelevant. A single-celled organism, it has many attributes of the 'nightmare bug' -it is difficult to detect, able to live for long periods in cold dark reservoirs and pipes, strikes large numbers of people and presents a threat to life for the elderly, very young and immuno-compromised. It is unclear how it is able to survive chlorination although it is believed that its protective 'oocyst' membrane plays a role. One theory is that the organism might use a pump mechanism to expel toxins from its inside before they cause it harm. Whatever its defence, it is effective: a study by the US Environmental Protection Agency suggested that Cryptosporidium could even live on Chlorine products. Although difficult to detect it is still relatively rare in most well maintained public water systems. The greatest danger is to people who use private water supplies. These supplies are, of course, tested. Research* in the United Kingdom suggests effective screening requires very frequent analysis of water samples. With less advanced filtration systems in private water supplies, the organism is able to pass easily, often escaping detection by hiding in the biofilm of the water system. By 1992 cases of Cryptosporidium in the United States had reached the same level as those of Giardia, until then the most common microbial contaminant in water supplies. Cases in Europe also increased. With Cryptosporidium's apparent resistance to disinfection and its ability to slip through any but the best kept filtration systems, the onus is on health agencies and water suppliers to invest in effective detection systems. As a contaminant of the water supply, the organism has the potential to infect large numbers of people particularly where water supplies serve densely populated urban areas. It is the scale of potential harm that puts Cryptosporidium in the first league of emerging pathogens. Cryptosporidium in Water Supplies
The 1989, in the United Kingdom, an outbreak in Swindon was the first time the country's public health authorities became aware of the potential scale of the problem. Cryptosporidium is excreted in huge numbers and is capable of surviving for long periods in the environment. It can also be passed on as a secondary infection as it requires a low infective dose of less than 100 organisms. The volume of water sample required to screen the water supply has to be large, often as much as 20 litres. With such a small number of organisms diffused in a large volume of water, it is easy to see how the organisms escape detection. Health Action
Private Water Supplies
Transfer interrupted!r risk from the proximity of farm waste and septic tanks. It is far better to prevent contamination entering a water supply than relying on treatment at the end of the pipe. This emphasises the need for frequent testing and the benefits of converting to well-maintained public water supplies. Further information on private water suppplies can be in found in Cryptosporidium and giardia lamblia in private water supplies by David Clapham & Natasha Franklin. Environmental Health. Issue no. 6/6. June 1998.Return to the top CRYPTOSPORIDIOSIS (krip-to-spo-rid-e-ó-sis)What is cryptosporidiosis? Cryptosporidiosis is a disease caused by the parasite Cryptosporidium parvum, which as late as 1976 was not known to cause disease in humans. Until 1993, when over 400,000 people in Milwaukee, Wisconsin, became ill with diarrhea after drinking water contaminated with the parasite, few people had heard of either cryptosporidiosis or the single-celled intestinal protozoon that causes it. Since the Milwaukee outbreak, concern about the safety of drinking water in the United States has increased, and new attention has been focused on determining and reducing the risk for cryptosporidiosis from community and municipal water supplies. How is cryptosporidiosis spread? Cryptosporidiosis is spread by putting something in the mouth that has been contaminated with the stool of an infected person or animal. In this way, people swallow the Cryptosporidium parasite, which is too small to be seen with the naked eye. A person can become infected by drinking contaminated water or eating raw or undercooked food contaminated with Cryptosporidium oocysts (an egg-like form of the parasite that is the infectious stage); direct contact with the droppings of infected animals or stool of infected humans; or hand-to-mouth transfer of oocysts from surfaces that may have become contaminated with microscopic amounts of stool from an infected person or animal. What are the symptoms of cryptosporidiosis? Two to ten days after infection by the parasite, symptoms may appear. Although some persons may not have symptoms, others have watery diarrhea, headache, abdominal cramps, nausea, vomiting, and low-grade fever. These symptoms may lead to weight loss and dehydration. In otherwise healthy persons, these symptoms usually last 1 to 2 weeks, at which time the immune system is able to stop the infection. In persons with suppressed immune systems, such as persons who have AIDS or recently have had an organ or bone marrow transplant, the infection may continue and become life-threatening. What should you do if you suspect that you have cryptosporidiosis? See your physician. Since the routine stool examination used for most parasites usually fails to detect Cryptosporidium, a stool specimen should be examined using stains/tests available especially for this parasite. It is important for persons with a poorly functioning immune system to seek medical attention early in the course of their disease. What is the treatment for cryptosporidiosis? No safe and effective cure is available for cryptosporidiosis. People who have normal immune systems improve without taking antibiotic or antiparasitic medications. The treatment recommended for this diarrheal illness is to drink plenty of fluids and to get extra rest. Physicians may prescribe medication to slow the diarrhea during recovery. Who is at risk? Persons at increased risk for cryptosporidiosis include child care workers; diaper-aged children who attend child care centers; persons exposed to human feces by sexual contact; and caregivers who might come in direct contact with feces while caring for a person infected with cryptosporidiosis at home or in a medical facility. Once infected, persons with suppressed immune systems, such as cancer chemotherapy patients, are at risk for severe disease. How can you prevent cryptosporidiosis?
HIV-infected persons should avoid drinking water directly from lakes or rivers; avoid unpasteurized milk or milk products; avoid exposure to calves and lambs and places where these animals are raised; wash hands after contact with pets; and wash hands after gardening or other contact with soil. Because any sexual activity that brings a person in contact with the feces of an infected partner greatly increases the risk for cryptosporidiosis, HIV-infected persons and AIDS patients should follow safer sex guidelines and avoid sexual practices that may result in contact with feces. If you are a caregiver of cryptosporidiosis patients, wash hands after bathing patients, emptying bedpans, changing soiled linen, or otherwise coming in contact with the stools of patients. If you have cryptosporidiosis, wash your hands often to prevent spreading
the disease to other members of your household.
For more information on cryptosporidiosis, see the following sources: Cordell RL, Addiss DG. Cryptosporidiosis in child care settings: a review of the literature and recommendations for prevention and control. Pediatr Infect Dis J. 1994;13(4):310-7. Dubey JP, Speer CA, Fayer R. Cryptosporidiosis of man and animals. Boston: CRC Press, 1990. LeChevallier MW, Norton WD, Lee RG. Giardia and Cryptosporidium spp. in filtered drinking water supplies. Appl Environ Microbiol 1991;57(9):2617-21. MacKenzie WR, Hoxie NJ, Proctor ME, Gradus MS, Blair KA, Peterson DE, Kazmierczak JJ, Addiss DG, Fox KR, Rose JB, Davis JP. A massive outbreak in Milwaukee of Cryptosporidium infection transmitted through the filtered public water supply. N Engl J Med 1994; 331:161-7. Rose JB, Gerba CP, and Jakubowski W. Survey of potable water supplies for Cryptosporidium and Giardia. Environmental Science and Technology 1991;25(8):1393-1400. Smith PD, Quinn TC, Strober W, Janoff EN, Masur H. Gastrointestinal infections in AIDS. Ann Intern Med 1992;116:63-77. National Center for Infectious Diseases Division of Parasitic Diseases
CRYPTOSPORIDIUM (UK)(Note: This Position Statement was subsequently published in Food Science & Technology Today, 11 (1), 46-48, March 1997). SUMMARYCryptospiridium parvum is a parasitic protozoan that causes cryptosporidiosis, an enteric infection in humans and animals. In people it causes abdominal pain, profuse diarrhoea, weight loss, loss of appetite and anorexia, but the infection is usually self-limiting and resolves within a few weeks. In immunocompromised patients the infection is more serious; it can become chronic and is sometimes fatal. These protozoa complete their life cycles in one host and their oocysts (spores) are highly infectious.The oocysts are usually transmitted by contaminated water, infected animals, person-to-person spread or contaminated food (C.parvum requires a host to multiply in, and cannot grow in foods or water). Water treatment plants cannot usually guarantee to remove all C.parvum from water because the oocysts are very small and resistant to chlorine. At pres> Transfer interrupted!ds on limiting contamination of input water by animals, manure or sewage, and by careful maintenance of water treatment systems. C.parvum is inactivated by heat, freezing and drying, so heat-treated, frozen and dried foods should be safe unless contaminated after processing.BACKGROUNDCryptospiridium parvum is a protozoan belonging to the Coccidia subclass. In humans it causes cryptosporidiosis, an intestinal infection. It also infects many animal species, causing symptomatic illnesses mainly in young animals Older animals may be carriers.The organism was discovered early in the twentieth century but its importance was only realised in the 1970s by veterinary workers investigating the causes of scours in young farm animals. Many of the early human cases were noted in the 1980s as serious infections in severely immunocompromised patients including AIDS sufferers Now widely recognised as an enteric pathogen with a world-wide distribution, it is endemic in some areas. Infection rates are highest in developing countries and in children. Many animal species can be infected and C.parvum is readily passed from animals to humans. CRYPTOSPORIDIOSISAn incubation period of 2-14 days follows ingestion of oocysts. Very low doses are able to initiate an infection, probably less than 100 oocysts. The protozoa attach to the wall of the gut and reproduce by means of a complex life cycle (see below). The illness is characterised by a profuse watery diarrhoea with abdominal pain. It can also cause vomiting, weight loss, loss of appetite and a low grade fever. Typically the illness resolves in 2-3 weeks but it can last for up to 6 weeks. Only supportive treatment is available, and this will only be required in serious cases. However, in severely immunocompromised patients, e.g. AIDS sufferers, the infection may become chronic and serious, sometimes fatal. In these cases other organs and tissues may become infected, e.g. the biliary tract and respiratory system. No antibiotic treatment has yet been shown to be effective in clinical use, although some encouraging results following use of paromomycin have been reported.Mature oocysts are excreted in faeces. Excretion may stop fairly promptly after the cessation of diarrhoea or it may continue at low levels for some weeks even after all symptoms of illness have gone. The parasite is transmitted by the faecal oral route and infection may be acquired in a number of ways: -- from contaminated water
Farmyard manure may contain high numbers of cryptosporidial oocysts and consequently water may be contaminated by manure or slurry washed off fields into rivers; vegetable crops may be contaminated by direct manuring of the fields in which they are grown. Well managed and stored manure and slurry is effective in reducing infectivity through raised temperature and ammonia levels. OUTBREAKSThe provisional figure for the number of reported cases in England and Wales in 1994 was 4424 (compared with about 30,000 reported cases of infection with Salmonella spp.) but, as many cases are thought to be unreported, the actual number of cases is probably several times higher. Cryptosporidiosis may show a seasonal distribution and at peaks it may be the commonest enteric pathogen being isolated from children. In one 2-year UK study C.parvum was found twice as often as Salmonella spp. in children aged l to 5 years. It is also recognised as a frequent cause of "traveller's diarrhoea". In countries where water supplies are often contaminated, malnutrition is evident, sanitation non-existent and close contact with animals is normal, infection rates can be high.The largest recognised outbreak was in Milwaukee USA in l993 when it was estimated that some 400,000 people may have been affected by contaminated drinking water In the UK there have been several outbreaks associated with farm visits and some well-publicised water-borne outbreaks. There were about 500 confirmed cases in the Spring of 1989 in the Swindon area; a contaminated reservoir was implicated. In the Summer of 1995 there were over 500 confirmed cases in Devon and drinking water was the suspected source. LIFE CYCLEC.parvum is an obligate parasite and has a complex life cycle that is completed in one host. The transmissible stage is the oocyst (spore). After ingestion each oocyst releases four motile sporozoites into the gut, primarily in the small bowel. These attach to the gut wall and develop by two asexual stages, producing merozoites and a sexual stage producing zygotes which sporulate to produce two types of oocysts. These stages develop just inside the outer walls of the cells lining the gut; the infection is intracellular but it is extracytoplasmic i.e. the protozoa do not penetrate deeply into the host's cells.Oocysts mostly sporulate within the gut and two types are produced. The thin-walled type releases more sporozoites in the gut (auto infection) and the thick-walled types are excreted in faeces in a fully infective form. They do not need any further maturation, unlike many other Coccidian protozoa. RESISTANCE OF OOCYSTSOocysts can remain viable for about 18 months in a cool damp or wet environment. They are quite common in rivers and lakes, especially where there has been sewage or animal contamination. However drying at ambient temperatures effectively reduces the infectivity of oocysts. They are destroyed by freezing and they are also heat sensitive. A temperature of 65 deg C inactivates oocysts in 5-10 minutesOocysts are remarkably resistant to many common disinfectants, including chlorine-based compounds Very high concentrations of disinfectant may be effective, but such levels are not practical for water treatment. WATER TREATMENTThe complete removal of C.parvum from water supplies is difficult, even for modern water treatment plants. The oocysts are resistant to the normal chlorine disinfection treatment and as they are very small (4-6 µm diameter) that means that they may pass through the filtration systems. Control measures include not using water sources polluted by run off from land contaminated by animals or otherwise contaminated with manure or sewage; good maintenance and design of the filtration systems, (flocculation and slow sand filtration is thought best), and careful control of the treatment facility and processes. The use of 1 µm pore size filtration systems would eliminate the parasite, but such systems are usually only available for low volume water through-puts. In practice, current technology is not adequate to guarantee the complete removal of these protozoa from water supplies.In view of this, both English and American public health authorities have recently (1995) advised severely immunocompromised people to boil drinking water in order to reduce the chance of acquiring waterborne cryptosporidiosis. (Bottled water is not guaranteed free of C.parvum) . It is sufficient simply to bring water to the boil to eliminate C.parvum. It should be stressed that to be effective the guidance must be followed consistently for all water used for drinking or for washing foods intended for consumption without cooking. FOODC.parvum cannot grow in food, but oocysts will survive in wet/moist foods if they become contaminated. Raw milk, raw sausages and offal are the most likely foods to be contaminated. Other foods including fruit and vegetables could be at risk if in contact with manure or contaminated water. Cooked foods are not thought to be at risk; the normal recommended time and temperature for controlling bacterial food poisoning (cooking to an internal temperature of 70 deg C for 2 minutes) will probably inactivate C.parvum. Heat processed foods have never been shown to be a source of infection.There is a potential danger that infected food handlers could contaminate food; people with symptoms must not handle foods and advice should be taken on when they can restart such work (usually at least 48 hours after symptoms resolve). Personal hygiene is very important with this illness because the infective dose is so low. DETECTIONThere is no way of amplifying by culture low numbers of C.parvum contaminating food to levels where they may be readily detected, hence examination of foods for this protozoan is not practical.Organisms in water samples can be concentrated by filtration followed by centrifugation. Deposits are then usually examined microscopically and immunofluorescent methods are now available. Newer methods include concentration by flocculation and detection by flow cytometry prior to microscopic examination. Identification of viable and non-viable oocysts from environmental and faecal samples relies upon direct microscopy and differential staining techniques, but this requires considerable expertise. Cryptosporidiosis is diagnosed after oocysts have bean detected in faecal samples. ELISA methods may be used for serodiagnosis. Further readingCasemore D P, Epidemiological aspects of human cryptosporidiosis, Epidemiol. Infect., 1990 , 104, 1-28DoE DOH, Cryptosporidium in Water Supplies, Second Report of the Group of Experts, HMSO, 1995, ISBN 0 11 753136 7 DoE DoH, Cryptosporidium in Water Supplies, HMSO, 1990, ISBN 0 11 75Z322 4 GlossaryZygote: a simple, diploid cell formed by the fusion of two gametes.Oocyst: an encysted zygote. Sporozoite: a motile cell produced in the oocyst by mitotic division. Merozoite: a motile, uninucleate cell arising from asexual division. The Institute of Food Science & Technology (IFST) is the independent professional qualifying body for food scientists and technologists. It is totally independent of government, of industry, and of any lobbying groups or special interest groups. Its professional members are elected by virtue of their academic qualifications and their relevant experience, and their signed undertaking to comply with the Institute's ethical Code of Professional Conduct. They are elected solely in their personal capacities and in no way representing organisations where they may be employed. They work in a variety of areas, including universities and other centres of higher education , research institutions, food and related industries, consultancy, food law enforcement authorities, and in government departments and agencies. The nature of the Institute and the mixture of these backgrounds on the working groups drafting IFST Position Statements, and on the two Committees responsible for finalising and approving them, ensure that the contents are entirely objective. IFST recognises that research is constantly bringing new knowledge. However, collectively the profession is the repository of existing knowledge in its field. It includes researchers expanding the boundaries of knowledge and experts seeking to apply it for the public benefit. Its purposes are
|
|
|
© Copyright 2001 ProLife Aqua Systems.